Easy Homemade Eggnog Recipe

Why I Love This Easy To Make Eggnog

To begin, my easy-to-make eggnog has alcohol in it - for some, this is the only way to drink it! When I was younger, I would buy eggnog at the store, and it wasn't enjoyable. If that's the only eggnog you've ever tried, I would encourage you to give this eggnog a try.

Secondly, this eggnog is creamy, full of flavor, and super easy to make! Plus, it's inspired by Alton Brown's eggnog, you know it's great!

How To Make Homemade Eggnog

This was my first time making eggnog, and I have a few tips to share in case you'd like to make this eggnog your own!

Tip # 1 - leave out the alcohol for an alcohol-free version!

Tip # 2 - for a creamier consistency, use 1.5 cups whole milk & 1.5 cups heavy whipping cream and leave out the half & half.

Tip # 3 - add cinnamon into or on top of the drink for more warmth

Tip # 4 - if you prefer cooked eggs, combine dairy & nutmeg in a pot and boil, stirring occasionally. Remove from heat, and allow to cool for a few minutes. Pour a little of the hot mixture into a bowl and mix a little of the egg & sugar mixture. Continue to add a little hot mixture and a little egg mixture until all is combined. Doing it slowly will temper the eggs, and you won't end up with scrambled eggs. Once all dairy and egg are combined, heat to 160 degrees F, allow to cool slightly, then add in alcohol and mix well. Then proceed with placing in jars in the fridge.

How To Make It Alcohol-Free

Simply omit the alcohol if you want an alcohol free eggnog. Note that the shelf life will be significantly less without the alcohol; enjoy within a week.

Making this alcohol-free is a great way to get all the flavor of eggnog without the alcohol burn that sometimes happens. Also, having it alcohol free allows guests to add any alcohol they like.

If I made alcohol free eggnog, I would add pumpkin pie spice, nutmeg, cinnamon & a little salt for added flavor.

Best Spices

Leaving the eggnog plain with no additional spices allows for guests to decide how much spice they would like. Spices can either be a spice blend like pumpkin pie spice and/or individual spices such as cinnamon, nutmeg, sugar, or a pinch of cayenne pepper for a kick.